LLC Operating Agreement Defeats Unjust Enrichment and Breach of Fiduciary Duty Claims

WOSS, LLC v. 218 ECKFORD, LLC, 102 AD 3d 860 - NY: Appellate Div., 2nd Dept. 2013 - Google Scholar:

The plaintiff LLC was a member of the defendant LLC 218 Eckford. It then brought numerous claims against the defendant LLC on the ground that it had not received the appropriate share of profits. Plaintiff's claims were entirely defeated because plaintiff was a member of 281 Eckford and signed the operating agreement. Plaintiff could not bring a claim for unjust enrichment because the operating agreement (a written contract) controlled the outcome. Plaintiff could not bring a claim for breach of fiduciary duty because plaintiff did not allege a fiduciary relationship.

Comment: the lesson here is that the operating agreement was thoughtfully drafted. The provisions of the operating agreement are a contract that governed the parties' business relationship. There were no holes in the agreement (at least according to the court) for the plaintiff to run through to bring a cause of action.

In sum, where there is more than one person involved in a business venture or undertaking, the operating agreement is crucial. It governs the parties' business relationship. This is where legal work is most valuable to the entrepreneur. The lawyer can draft the agreement to reflect the client's wishes and can avoid many pitfalls.

Edward X. Clinton, Jr.

'via Blog this'